Mean Girls UK Tour Review: Edinburgh Playhouse Defies Chaos

Image

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Tina Fey’s high school satire hits the road with a sharp, updated script and a remarkably resilient cast. Despite an opening night plagued by technical collapse, this touring production proves itself a first-rate, genuinely funny comedy-drama.


Live theatre always runs on a certain amount of jeopardy, but the press night of the Mean Girls UK tour at the Edinburgh Playhouse pushed that to absurd extremes. Thanks to a spectacularly self-destructing PA system, the audience saw barely fifteen minutes of actual performance in the first hour. Yet, the evening ultimately triumphed, and that is down to a magnificent cast. They never dropped the ball, picking up the tempo after every abrupt reset to deliver a platinum-grade performance that refused to yield to the disaster unfolding around them.

They were aided, of course, by robust material. Two decades after its cinematic release, Tina Fey’s vicious map of high school social topography remains indestructible. Fey, alongside composer Jeff Richmond and lyricist Nell Benjamin, has cleverly updated the story for this stage iteration. It translates effectively, ensuring the mechanics of teenage cruelty remain familiar while avoiding the trap of feeling dated. Under Casey Nicholaw’s relentless direction and choreography, it proves itself a first-rate, genuinely funny comedy-drama even before the Broadway gloss is applied.

The Plastics and the Outcasts

The ensemble navigating this high-school jungle is largely superb. As our sardonic outcast guides, Janis (Georgie Buckland) and Damian (Max Gill) continually threaten to hijack the production, armed with a dry, crackling chemistry that undercuts the surrounding hysteria. Ruling the corridors is Regina George (Vivian Panka), who commands the room with an icy, regal stillness, flanked brilliantly by the gleaming, comedic timing of her lieutenants, the terminally insecure Gretchen (Kiara Dario) and gloriously vacant Karen (Sophie Pourret).

The only slight disconnect in an otherwise airtight principal lineup is Cady Heron (Emily Lane). Lane is undeniably talented, boasting a terrific voice and bounding across the stage with formidable energy. Yet, she brings a distinctly jolly-hockey-sticks, golden-retriever enthusiasm to a part that demands a sassier, darker descent into toxic narcissism.

“Yet, the evening ultimately triumphed, and that is down to a magnificent cast. They never dropped the ball, picking up the tempo after every abrupt reset to deliver a platinum-grade performance that refused to yield to the disaster unfolding around them.“

On the periphery, Jennifer Ellison takes on the heavy lifting of the adult track, pivoting between deadpan calculus teacher Ms. Norbury, boundary-free ‘cool mum’ Mrs. George, and earnest, grounded parent Mrs. Heron. Ellison boasts a capable voice and reliable comic timing, but the triple-hat demanding position needs someone with a stronger bent for character acting.

Punctuation and Polish

The score itself is a curious one. It is wonderfully produced and orchestrated, driven by a brass-heavy pit band that gives the evening genuine swagger. Yet, as a body of work, it is not particularly memorable. While Janis and Damian’s hilarious opening number and Regina and Karen’s respective solos have a little X-factor, you could scrap the remaining songs and still be left with a razor-sharp play. In a sense, the music functions less as a narrative engine and more as high-energy soundtrack for Nicholaw’s impressively choreographed dance numbers.

“While the opening number and Regina and Karen’s respective solos have a distinct X-factor, you could realistically scrap the remaining songs and still be left with a razor-sharp play.”

It’s a minor criticism, and it must be said that this beautifully produced, if utilitarian approach pays off in the show’s staging. Scott Pask’s old-school set design utilises simple, evocative painted drops and highly mobile props. Desks, lockers, and living room furnishings glide on and off seamlessly, facilitating the athletic song and dance numbers without ever screaming for attention or pulling focus from the comedy.

Mean Girls may not be a great musical, but it’s a great show all the same. Anything less would probably have fomented a theatrical revolt long before the company brought proceedings to a triumphant conclusion a few minutes after 11pm. To survive such a catastrophic opening meltdown and still stick the landing speaks to a cast armed with good material, plus enormous professionalism, and abundant nerve! Bravo!

Featured Image: The cast of Mean Girls. Photo by Paul Coltas.


Details

Show: Mean Girls

Venue: Edinburgh Playhouse

Dates: Tue 17 – Sat 21 Nov 2026

Running Time: 2 hours 30 minutes (including interval)

Age Guidance: 10+

Admission: From £30.00

Time: Evenings at 7:30pm; Wed & Sat matinees at 2:30pm

Accessibility: Wheelchair access (Circle level via Circle Bar), Sennheiser Infrared headsets

  • BSL Interpreted: Wed 18 Nov, 7:30pm (Signer Position: Stage Left)
  • BSL Interpreted: Thu 19 Nov, 7:30pm (Signer Position: Stage Left)

Mean Girls plays the Edinburgh Playhouse until Sat 21 November 2026, before continuing on national tour. For tickets or more information, click here: https://www.atgtickets.com/shows/mean-girls/edinburgh-playhouse/

Leave a Reply