Review: Cinders – Scottish Ballet – Glasgow

Bruno Micchiardi as Cinders and Jessica Fyfe as Princess Louise. Credit Andy Ross - Review at theQR.co.uk

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Some stories suffer when subject to too much re-interpretation, and Cinders, Scottish Ballet’s newest take on the Cinderella tale, is a good example. However, this has nothing to do with the production’s gender-swapping approach to the titular character. Indeed, there is no reason whatsoever, that Cinders should not be a boy, as Bruno Micchiardi’s expressive, sensitive inhabitation of the role demonstrates.

However, this reworking of the Cinderella story, though ambitious, suffers from bouts of muddied storytelling, Christopher Hampson‘s new version sees Designer Elin Steele create a gorgeous quasi-Edwardian world, in which little Cinders (Charles Waller), his Mother (Roseanna Leney), and Father (Rimbaud Patron), enjoy an idyllic life in their family draper’s shop. The suitably titled Rose family meet disaster when a fire claims both the shop and parents, leaving the boy orphaned. This prologue is handled very well through a mix of evocative choreography, warm lighting from Lawrie McLennan, and Hayley Egan’s newspaper headline projections.

Without any other explanation given, we must then assume Cinders lives in the ashes of the shop for years until the Thorne family moves in. Cinders is put to work, but doesn’t enjoy a healthy working relationship with new owner Mrs Thorne’s (Grace Paulley) children, Tarquin (Aaron Venegas), and Morag (Grace Horler). His new employer is no fan either, and when invitations to a Royal Ball arrive, she tears his up before his crying eyes. Hampson retains a more sympathetic, third sibling, as per his earlier stagings, and Claire Souet makes an endearingly awkward Flossie.

At this point, those who have not read the programme, and those who have will likely diverge. Those who have, will know that Cinder’s parents visit from beyond the vale to restore the invite, and in a prettily arranged enchanted rose garden, go one step further to attire him suitably and direct him to the ball. Those who have not will be left guessing because elegant and dreamlike though these sequences are, the narrative sign-posting is not strong enough. With no previous mention of rose gardens, an unremarkable transformation into a somewhat sparkly outfit, and no hint of midnight cut-offs the storytelling isn’t adequate.

The Royal Ball which closes the first Act is a lush affair, nevertheless, and Jessica Fyfe owns the floor as Princess Louise. Precise technique, and tremendously prepossessing, she strikes just the right regal tone. Fyfe comes alive to Prokofiev’s swelling melodic lines, intended for a Prince, but just as suited to a confident Princess. Hampson shows his flair for comedy when the ‘ugly’ children take the floor to impress the Princess and her friends, the Duke of Orleans (Yuri Marques) and the Duke of Tonnerre (Thomas Edwards). It takes a particular surfeit of skill to clown so effectively, and Horler, Souet and Venegas each make their mark. Cinders of course arrives, love at first sight occurs, and the rest is romantic history.

The short Second Act brings the story back on the expected path, opening with the Princess dreaming of her mystery man (who fled at midnight for no good reason, leaving a shoe behind), prompting a wonderful duet with Micchiardi bathed in dry ice. The action moves back to Thorne’s draper’s shop just in time for the royal hunt to enter bearing the orphan shoe. You can guess the rest. The closing montage is a very nice touch all the same, and if it rings closer to Barbara Taylor Bradford than the Brothers Grimm, it’s fitting with Hampson’s period romance vision. The details I’ll leave unmentioned should you wish a pleasant surprise.

On the other hand, the pairings-off, Cinders aside, does raise eyebrows when the odious Tarquin finds a happy ending with one of the Dukes. I delight in the representation, but bullies should not prosper in fairytales, irrespective of their sexual preferences.

On the other hand, the Scottish Ballet Orchestra under Wolfgang Heinz are uncontroversial in their excellence. From start to finish they lavish Prokofiev’s score with tremendous talent and passion. The deliciously tuneful score, however, demands a magical romance that never quite materialises on stage.

Cinders is a Scottish Ballet production.


Show Details – Glasgow

Dates: 9 – 31 December 2023


Showtimes:

  • 14:30/19:30

Age Recommendation: Family-friendly – parental discretion

Running Time: 

Accessibility


Cinders will play the Theatre Royal Glasgow until the 31st December. It will then play Edinburgh, Aberdeen, Inverness, and Newcastle. For tickets, and more information, click here.


Leave a Reply