Review: Arlington – Dance, Defiance and Dystopia at the Traverse

Image

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Enda Walsh’s 2016 play, Arlington, is theatre operating at the elusive, poetic end of the spectrum, and this Shotput production at the Traverse Theatre tackles that challenge head-on. Co-directed by Lucy Ireland and Jim Manganello, this Scottish premiere is a visually compelling, powerful realisation of Walsh’s abstract surveillance-state fable.


For ninety minutes, we are pulled into a chilling, Orwellian-adjacent world where the confined Isla (Aisha Goodman) dreams of a world she’s never known, whilst attempting to forge a human bond with her unseen observer, the Young Man (Alex Austin). The script itself is a gorgeous tangle of non-linear fragments, but it’s the accomplished direction and visceral physical language that give this production its undeniable, lingering power.

Enda Walsh’s Abstract Dystopia and the Power of Unseen Imagery

What makes this iteration so unnerving is how grounded its oppression feels. Designer Anna Yates anchors the space with an unsettling icon of bureaucracy: a row of three all-too-familiar plastic waiting-room chairs, placed on a raised platform, watched over by a control desk below. This clinical landscape is both strange and instantly recognisable, making the existential horror feel acutely possible.

This is where we must acknowledge that Walsh defies easy understanding. The play isn’t interested in the logistics of its totalitarian state; it’s interested in the feeling of being trapped by it. Consequently, Arlington is rich with deliberate, powerful symbolism, the meaning of which is left entirely to the individual watching it. For every piece of grim concrete, there is a dream-like glimpse of green space beyond the towers, hinting at a lost, natural world.

The script itself is a gorgeous tangle of non-linear fragments, but it’s the accomplished direction and visceral physical language that give this production its undeniable, lingering power.

Walsh’s powerful imagery extends beyond the visual, creating sounds so efficiently described we don’t need to hear them; the dialogue mentions the grim imagery of bodies falling from the anonymous high-rises that dominate the outside world, painting a picture of silent, widespread devastation without a single stage effect. The repeated, eerie appearance of seagulls is another key motif, their screeching calls acting as a shorthand for freedom and impossible escape.

Shotput’s Accomplished Staging: Traverse Theatre’s Technical Triumph

The technical team delivers a highly impressive sound-and-vision experience that solidifies this oppressive atmosphere. Rob Willoughby’s video design is meticulous, projecting live feeds that force the audience into the dreamer’s chair. This is married to Emma Jones’s sharp, clinical lighting and Garry Boyle’s menacing soundscape, which pulses with a mechanical, insistent energy.

Crucially, this unseen world is given texture by the skilled voice work of actors like Ann Louise Ross, Andy Clark, Pauline Goldsmith, and Benny Young, who collectively form the dehumanised, pervasive voice of the controlling state, occasionally interrupting the central drama with callous officialdom. The entire design works with precision to create a feeling of total containment, leaving no space for the audience—or the inhabitants—to breathe.

The Jack Anderson Solo: Dance, Defiance, and Diluted Narrative Impact

The emotional core of the play explodes in the central, wordless sequence that shatters the dialogue’s dominance. Directors Ireland and Manganello’s choreography is a qualified masterstroke, serving as a necessary catharsis for the script’s tension. Featuring dancer Jack Anderson, this extended passage is an aerobic, high-energy physical exploration of confinement. Anderson transforms the small platform into a volatile arena, his movements conveying the raw, suppressed fury, anxiety, and desperation of a confined mind.

The emotional core of the play explodes in the central, wordless sequence that shatters the dialogue’s dominance. Directors Ireland and Manganello’s choreography is a qualified masterstroke, serving as a necessary catharsis for the script’s tension.

It’s an arresting, brave piece of physical theatre that achieves what dialogue often cannot. Yet, as compelling and technically brilliant as the solo is, it risks running a few minutes too long, its significant impact slightly diluted by repetition. When the scene finally snaps back to the spoken narrative, it takes a moment for the audience to re-engage with the thread of the central human drama.

Aisha Goodman and Alex Austin Anchor the Unfinished Love Story

The poetry of Walsh’s script demands a tightrope performance, and the three leads deliver. Aisha Goodman brings an acerbic wit and determined resilience to Isla. She ensures Isla’s philosophical musings land with a gallows humour that keeps the piece from becoming schematic. Similarly, Alex Austin anchors the piece with measured restraint as the Young Man, portraying the fragility and vulnerability that makes his eventual decision—to join Isla and defy the system—feel earned.

This shared chemistry fuels what appears to be the play’s hopeful climax, yet Walsh, ever the provocateur, undercuts any easy resolution. The production ends with the suggestion of a ‘happy ending’ so neat it feels profoundly untrustworthy.

We’re left to wonder if the entire final act was nothing more than a shared, desperate flight of imagination—the most infuriating of dramatic devices: the possibility that it was all a dream. But perhaps that’s the point: that imagination is the only true escape afforded to the enslaved.

The Untrustworthy Ending: Imagination as the Only True Escape

Shotput’s Arlington is a powerful, technically impressive production that demands to be seen. It’s not a comfortable sit; Walsh’s intentional ambiguities—the lurking suspicion that our heroes never truly escaped, the brief structural sag following the dance—could leave viewers scratching their heads. But for those ready to embrace its unique blend of challenging fiction and visceral staging, it is a fiercely relevant, unforgettable, if inscrutable piece of theatre.

Featured Image: Arlington Photo_Brian Hartley

Details

Show: Arlington

Venue: Traverse 1, Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh

Dates: 6–8 November 2025

Running Time: Approx. 1 hour 30 mins

Age Guidance: 12+

Admission: Full Price £20; Concession £17; Students & U30s £15; Low Income Benefit Recipient £5

Time: Various; e.g. Fri 7 Nov 7:30pm; Sat 8 Nov 2:30pm & 7:30pm

Accessibility: Fully Accessible Venue: BSL-signed performance (7 Nov) and Audio Described performance (8 Nov). Contains smoke, haze, flashing lights, loud noises, strong language and themes of suicide.


Enda Walsh’s Arlington plays the Traverse Theatre until November 8th; for more information and to purchase tickets, click here: https://www.traverse.co.uk/whats-on/event/arlington-autumn-25


Leave a Reply